“My son was given a reading homework to do and one of the questions asked his to answer with his own ideas rather than just find the answer in the reading. How is he supposed to do that?” my friend asked.
Another friend responded to her, “that’s not comprehension!”
And then I simply said, “yes that is.” As often when a group of friends get together, it is hard to keep up with the torrent of conversation. Also, I didn’t want to be “Babara Boring-Pants” and go into a lecture about what reading comprehension is and isn’t on a coffee morning. I go to coffee to chill out with friends–not to do my job which is teach reading and writing to children with special needs.
However, I can write about my thoughts on it here. I started teaching reading in 2001 and have been an avid reader for years before that. However, before actually teaching children to read I had no idea about the process of reading and the skills needed to be an effective reader. It is a complex process, but this is intended to be just a beginning look at my understanding of reading.
Some of the earliest skills for reading start with learning to simply hold a book, knowing which way to turn the pages as well as an implicit understanding of the purpose of books. In most middle class households reading to children is a given and parents hold their child in their laps reading books almost as soon as they are born. Some children, unfortunately don’t get this and need to be taught this school in their nursery. (Which is why early education is so important and is a whole other topic.)
Another early reading skill is listening to sounds and beginning to separate sounds and words into bits. This is, in part, why there is so much singing in preschool and nursery settings. Children can start out singing the alphabet not really knowing what it’s all about, but later when they are introduced to the letters visually they can begin to connect the dots when they are ready. This is linked to children learning “phonics” and “sounding out words”. A beginning reader often starts by sounding out words such at b-a-t and linking those to make words. Children do a lot of this sounding out until there is a shift and they start to be able to recognise words as “sight words” or single units. As an adult reader, this is why you can read so fast since you are fluent in what the shapes of those words are.
As a teacher of the visually impaired, this is what can slow a lot of children’s reading since their vision means they have less exposure to environmental text in their world. In fact, one of my reading interventions with the children with VI that I do is to take them for a walk around school challenging them to find text on the walls. Often they haven’t noticed these words around them and have had little motivation to read environmental text. I try to make the text worthwhile for them so that they can get joy out of reading words. I still remember being a child on the southside of Chicago and being excited to read graffiti on the walls that had been spray painted on the walls on our school. It said “bird” and I can still see it in my minds eye.
So you’ve got a child holding a book properly, matching sounds to letters, sounding out words and recognising sight words like a champ. Hooray! They are a READER!! I say, celebrate that, but now is the time to hone those skilful reading skills. The child who can sound out and recognise words now needs to become a reading detective, picking up clues to read in between the lines using their own life experience and knowledge to understand what they are reading. Some children might be able to this naturally, but many need to be specifically taught how to do this.
I used to begin teaching inference when I taught primary via pictures and asking children to answer questions about them just by using what they saw. For example, looking at a photo of a girl with her mouth wide open and laughing, I’d ask the children to tell me what they thought she was feeling. The would say “happy”, “silly” or something like that. Then I’d ask, “why do you think that?” All of them could have a different answer–maybe she’d just been told a joke? More often than not they would all have had experience laughing as they are children and laugh much more easily than us adults. Some children, maybe who are on the autistic spectrum, might wonder why I am even bothering them with asking why this girl is laughing. That’s fine. I would have to address their needs in a different way that that is beyond my scope here. For the children with VI and certainly those who are blind, I can do this with sound or touch asking similar “why” questions.
We do higher level reading when we try to figure out new words by using the context to make sense. Through a grammatical structure we can make guesses as to what class of word it is such as a noun or a verb. We can also use our background knowledge to make guesses at its meaning as well as thinking about the theme of the reading and linking it to what we’ve read already. This is why I get children to talk about the titles of books and sections in their reading since they are there to give us clues to figure out what we are reading.
Often the children I teach have had limited life experiences having been sheltered by well meaning parents or their parents may not have had the life chances to take their child on weekly trips to the zoo or museum. Also, there may be chidlren who just don’t see the point of reading and have yet been shown the joys of it and motivated to read. That’s fine. I can only meet the child where they are.
Reading is, simply put, a big puzzle and as readers, we are adding up clues in the text and trying to figure out the meaning of the whole from the pieces we do understand. To do this really well, it helps to be comfortable taking risks and making guesses. For the “why” questions, I tell the children to “make their best guess”. I try to make them see that they know it already and that the right answer in their own answer. It can be a daunting thing to be told just “take a guess” when all the time children are confronted with ticks and x’s on their work clearly showing their errors. As a teacher, I aim to get children to begin to take their own thoughts seriously. All children have opinions about everything. How often have I heard my own children complain about the meal I’ve made them? All children can read critically and have an opinion–with guidance they can begin to identify just what exactly they like and express their thoughts about a text. Getting children to be comfortable to express that is a challenge, but well worth it.
What do you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts. Do you notice your deeper reading skills in your own reading?






